Q. Will you please tell me where is Phil Harvey(the mysterious 5th member) is in the Life in Technicolor ii music video. He holds a video camera is a clue you have given to us but there are 3 people holding cameras.

Q. Is the fifth member Phil really a dog?
If so, what kind?

Q. Hey Oracle!
I was looking at the cassette tape for Ode to Deodorant, and it has Phil's number on it. Could I still contact him on it, or is he guilty of false advertising after all these years?

Thanks!

Q. Hi Oracle

Had Phil had any previous experience in management? It seems quite fascinating that someone inexperienced could take the band so far. Was Phil just smart and talented enough to learn the ropes quickly?

Thanks

Q. Dear Oracle,
I am currently watching my tenth run of the Live 2003 Tour Diary today, and I haven't noticed Phil anywhere! Is he in the diary or not?
Thank you.

Q. Hi Oracle,
Why does Phil Harvey play in the back and not on stage?
Thanks,
Angela

Q. In a previous oracle question, you answered when the bands birthdays were. But we noticed that missed Phil's birthday even though he is the 5th member. So we were just wondering when his birthday was?