May 5, 2009 - submitted by Dot, United Kingdom

Q. Dear Oracle,

In Roadie 42's latest blog, he said that before X&Y, only Will did backup vocals, but in the Live 2003 DVD I thought I saw Jonny on backup as well. Am I remembering things incorrectly?

The Oracle replies:

You're right, Jonny was singing backing vocals from a very early stage. Followed by Will, Guy was the last to brave the idea.